Signals Machine

This is an entry for a Forex product called Signals Machine. The official site for this product is at signalsmachine.com. If you’re looking for more info about this product follow the link.

If you’re looking for reviews for Signals Machine, find them below. The reviews come from real users so if you don’t see any comments yet, please check back soon.

If you have experience with this product, please leave a short review or comments with your feedback. It will help other users to decide. Thanks!

If you want to submit a Forex product that is not already listed on this site for user comments and review, use the submission form.

60 thoughts on “Signals Machine”

  1. I have just purchased this signals system which comes with all the bells and whistles and uses three trading strategies plus you can buy an ea clone to trade automatically, totalling in all around $80. So far I am very impressed with the on chart guides and comprehensive inputs
    Will let you know how it goes.

  3. I have never personally heard of Tal Herman until my inbox was flooded this past wk by all the affiliates pitching me his new system, lol! But unlike 8 out of 10 new EA’s & systems I see, this is one that I am actually interested in finding out more about. For one thing, the longer timeframes, in this case the 1hr, makes sense as a trader who doesn’t like to bother w scalping. The excessively fast & ‘noisy’ 1min, 5min, and even the 15min charts sometimes gets a bit too volatile for my trading style, and I have found that most of the time I lose money much faster than I make it (only on demo, thank heavens!) I like that you can just use Mr Herman’s signals system alacarte if you prefer, reasonably priced at 69.00 -and thereby enter and exit a trade using your own discretion and applying your own experience and perhaps verifying entries and exits using your own indicators on a separate chart. Or get the more deluxe pkg of the signals w the additional handy robot to assist you, again it to seems to be pretty reasonably priced at 89.00. I admit however, as good as any of the recent EA’s have become compared to earlier ones, I still wouldn’t completely trust ANY robot yet w a live money account! But that’s just me, I’ll bet there are plenty of traders around the world that have made some very good money w their EA’s doing the heavy lifting, albeit w some close supervision -especially during periods of unusual volatility. I am hoping he won’t try to hit you w upsells and desperate offers of free junk just to close the sale (that we all already have several times over ha ha!)
    I like discounts, by HATE stinking upsells and never accept them. Either a product is good enough on its own merits, or it isn’t. Don’t try to nail me for another 50. or 100. AFTER I started buying and have entered my CC info! Folks closing w all these rinky dink upsells make me think of the old stereotypical image of the shady used car salesman w his hideous plaid jacket and bowtie calling you ‘friend’ to make you lower your guard, lol! I’m favorably impressed by the ‘Signals Machine’ website, It’s very professional looking from my POV, seems well organized, and thorough enough in details, and best of all has omitted the usual stupid ‘Forex Trading as seen on CNBC, FOX, Bloomberg, etc’, lol! To my mind, that gives it a little air of credibility most system and EA sellers lack. And the usual 60 day ClickBank guarantee certainly will help make the sale for those sitting on the fence, myself included! 😉 Tal Herman’s system supposedly works best w the GBP/USD (as does the SRS Trend Rider system) but seems OK to use on any pair. I very much like the GBP/USD and have traded it, but normally trade the EUR/USD most sessions and am naturally curious how well the ‘Signals Machine’ will deal w it. Lastly, I want to thank the Admin for the recent article additions (found under the recent posts column) I liked reading them and it never hurts to brush up on ones general trading knowledge. I no longer just visit FPA (Forex Peace Army) w/o also stopping by here now 2 or 3 times a wk.

  4. Hi

    I’ve purchased Signals Machine today and am using it on the GBPUSD60 chart as advised and it has already made $5 tading 0.1 lots. I’ve now adjusted the settings so my lot size is 0.75. It is a clean product to install and the supplied documentation is clear and understandable. The product has been running for about an hour and so far has generated one profitable trade and I’ve entered a buystop trade as suggested by the second signal. So far, very impressed but it is very early days so will see how it runs this week and next. If still generating positive pips I’ll let it loose on a live account. I’ve only taken the basic package so the software suggests a buy / sell trade and it is upto me to take the trade or not so there is still some control required on my part which suits me fine.

    In terms of upsells, over and above the two options I saw on the website, there is only one more which is a trade cloner package from the author himself. This does not seem unreasonable to me if he is doing the work and your MT4 is mirroring.

    I’ve tried two previous products before (pips4idiots and stealth forex signals) and had to get refunds as they simply did not work and were poorly packaged. I’m hoping this Signals Machine product will deliver.

    I’ll post more later 🙂

    Thanks for your time.
    Lee

  6. Yes, thank you Lee for sharing! I will check back on your follow ups. Also, how much was the trade cloner package?

    Thanks,
    Matt

  8. Hi Again

    I’m 3 for 3 using Signals Update. In my earlier post I made $5 with 0.1 size lots so I changed the settings so lot size is now 0.75.

    I have manually closed two trades as setup by Signals Machine as they were near TP level but this was at the same time as a news event affecting the GBPUSD pair so closed the trades to avoid volatility.

    The great news is that 1 trade made 19 pips $142.50 and the 2nd trade netted 22 pips $165.00. Today there have been 3 completed trades and I have made 46 pips using this package alone 🙂

    As mentioned before I will continue to test and monitor and report my findings but this product has more than paid for itself with one day’s testing.

  9. Awoke to my 4th successful trade and the product has made another 30 pips $225 profit. This trade was fully managed by Signals Machine and I did not intervene. In 2 days I have made 76 pips over 4 trades and no loss trades. 😀

  10. My trading with Signals Machine is now 5 for 5. Just made 29 pips $217.50. Have now adjusted lot size from 0.75 to 1.0. Cumulative pips in 2 days is now 105 pips!!!

  12. I have done some trades with the Sig machine and think it is good. For now, I can’t get the cloner to work. It actually says it has connected and is waiting for trade but has not registered any trade yet. Can someone help me out?

  13. Yes Joseph, no any trade registered by cloner. But I think it because of one of the Tal Herman’s rules. The signal come out with Strategy 3 – Extreme Breakout.
    Look what Tal Herman has said at his Signal Machine Strategy Guide -:

    “And now, let me share with you my personal statistics and my trading history with this strategy and share with you my HIGHLY RECOMMENDED RULES!!!
    I trade with this strategy every beginning of the month. At the 1st of every month I start trading it. My total loss that I’m ready to take is 100 pips, and my monthly target is also 100 pips. Not 100 pips per trade, but 100 in total!!!

    You might ask yourself, why 100 pips? Why not 200 or 500 pips??? Well the answer is simple. 100 pips of profit is 10% profit on your balance if you use for every trade with this strategy leverage 1:10. For example, your account is $1,000, so you should trade $10,000 trades, or 0.1 standard lot. With 0.1 standard lot, every pip is $1, so if you earn 100 pips you earn $100 which are 10% from your account, $1,000.
    The second reason is that it is not simple to be intraday trader. If you don’t have real targets and limits, you might make psychological mistakes that will harm your profits. That’s why I personally highly recommend to use small and realistic targets and limits, so if you reach them, stop trading this strategy.
    During my history, the target or the limit are reached during the first 3-5 days of the month.”

    Today is 18th maybe he waiting other signal strategy.

  15. @Dean

    Currently running on demo mode but using strict money mgmt techniques, i.e. current fund size is $12,500 and am risking $200 per trade (this is 1.0 lot size x stop loss of 20). This equates to 1.6%. It is too soon for me personally to use this in a live account. I intend trialling it for 2 weeks and then will introduce onto a live account.

    The product has made 12 trades since purchase(10 wins, 2 losses) with profits currently at $1285.00

    2011.01.17 16:56 buy 0.10 gbpusd 1.5895 1.5900 1.5948 2011.01.17 17:24 1.5900 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.00
    2011.01.18 02:56 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5926 1.5906 1.5956 2011.01.18 08:33 1.5956 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    2011.01.18 01:09 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5918 1.5898 1.5948 2011.01.18 07:50 1.5948 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    2011.01.17 20:54 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5888 1.5868 1.5918 2011.01.18 01:03 1.5910 0.00 0.00 0.00 165.00
    2011.01.17 23:00 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5891 1.5867 1.5923 2011.01.18 01:03 1.5910 0.00 0.00 0.00 142.50
    2011.01.18 02:56 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5925 1.5905 1.5955 2011.01.18 08:33 1.5955 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    2011.01.18 10:03 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5981 1.5960 1.6010 2011.01.18 10:30 1.6010 0.00 0.00 0.00 217.50
    2011.01.18 10:30 buy 2.00 gbpusd 1.6018 0.0000 0.0000 2011.01.18 10:30 1.6026 0.00 0.00 0.00 160.00
    2011.01.18 18:36 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5963 1.5983 1.5933 2011.01.18 18:50 1.5983 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    2011.01.18 20:59 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.5978 1.5958 1.6008 2011.01.18 21:05 1.5958 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    2011.01.18 21:30 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5963 1.6004 1.5896 2011.01.18 21:50 1.5961 0.00 0.00 0.00 20.00
    2011.01.18 22:25 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.5964 1.5944 1.5994 2011.01.19 02:28 1.5994 0.00 0.00 0.00 300.00

    There are currently 5 sell stops and 1 buy stop as pending orders.

    So far this product has delivered.

    For everyone else’s benefit I will now not interfere manually with trades made by SM and see how it copes. I think this will be useful as it removes discretion and will force the product to use it’s own rules.

  16. This is my first day of running the signals machine plus cloner on a live account. I have had 2 trades, both for losses. I am trading at 0.25. I did not realise that once live trading started Leverage inhibits the amount you can trade with.
    As far as the cloner goes, I spoke with someone from the company this morning, and they have informed me that TAL only trades 2 – 3 a week (if he feels as though the market is right).
    My opinion of the package at the moment. Totally undecided. I to work with the demo model and did quite well, however after starting the live account, the machine seems to faulter.
    I trust things will get better

  18. The program in my opinion does not work to produce consistant profits. Most of the signals produced trade as a loss.
    Also one has to be near the computer 24/5.

  20. Hello Traders,
    Purchased the upsell Cloner and all set up. Appears once Cloner’s on, it shuts down the TMR? TMR data on the upper left corner disappears when the Cloner data on the upper right is on. If this is the case, can we run TMR on another platform to trade separately? Have a message into SM but still waiting. Thanks!

  21. I found the day I purchased this software (17 Jan) and yesterday the product worked fine but today has been shocking. I have lost 100 pips today.

    It would appear this product does not like it when the market is choppy. If it’s trending then the product works.

    I’m only using it in demo mode so there are no real risks at the present but it just goes to show you “make sure you always test new products in demo mode”. I will add that you should test it over a range of trading conditions too.

    Not concerned at the moment but a little disappointed by performance today.

    I will update tomorrow with the trade results.

  22. Lee,
    Assuming your 100 pip trade loss was per TMR and not Cloner? Can you confirm? I’m on the Cloner and no trades so far. However, did get an email from Tal explaining why there have been no trades the past few days.

  23. @ FX Cutie
    My understanding is the Cloner (add on) copies Tal’s personal trades onto our MT4 platform. (replicator…similar to LTP?)

    The TMR (non cloner) is a signal service delivered via MT4, voice and/or email with 1 touch order execution.

  25. @K-Boy

    I’m using TMR (signals built into MT4). Tal did send me an email last night detailed below. I am going to RTFM a few times as it is too early to draw firm conclusions about this product. Of the EA’s I’ve reviewed this one has the cleanest installation and best documentation so this for me is a positive plus Tal has followed up with this email.

    **

    Tal here, and first of all I would like to thank you for adopting my Signals Machine into your trading world.

    I’ve been asked why there were no trades on the Signals Machine Cloner this week. I also wanted to advice the manual (non-cloner) Signals Machine users to be extremely cautious in the next fewdays! Why?

    As I’ve explained on the Strategy Guide that comes with the
    Signals Machine, the Extreme Breakout strategy, the most active strategy of the trio, provides the best results at the beginning of the month. We are no longer at a month beginning and on top of that the market is experiencing a very problematic period.

    This mainly stems from fundamental reasons such as speculations about US credit, the European crisis, and the Great Britain speculations regarding King’s interest rate decisions and inflationary pressures.

    What does it mean practically? The highs and lows that have been broken, quickly retraced. Had I been less cautious and taken the signals despite the “beginning of month” recommendation, you would have probably gotten 3-4 losses, not pleasant.

    You need to understand that when the market is not clear, and makes many up and down intraday moves, the probability of getting a real true move is low!

    What I do in my own personal account is what you get in the Signals Machine Cloner, and if you haven’t got a trade it means I didn’t think the probability of reward is worth the risk. I treat my account very cautiously, and I don’t trade just for the sake of trading! I trade to win and I don’t settle for second-rate trades.

    So, there would be days with 4-6 trades, and days with zero trades such as the last few days.

    I really hope that you understand this point, and will allow me to do my job in the best way possible, as I always strive to do. Even if it means waiting patiently for a few days, I’d rather you’d be happy with the good and less frequent trades, rather than being upset at a stupid trading decision I made. Such a trap, in this current market period, is unfortunately easy to fall into.

    So, your patience is appreciated and thanks again for being an owner of the Signals Machine!

    **

    I’ll check in later with a trade update 🙂

  26. Another upsetting day…I can understand that the market may be unstable, however when the machine is picking drops when in reality it turns out to be unstoppable highs (i begin to wonder). same same, finally 1 cloner trade, for a loss. Is it to early to consider refund?????
    1 from 7 today..

  28. Update on the Cloner:
    Trade #2 for a 29 pip winner per TP. Net +5 after 2 trades.

    @Alister: IMO, need to give this a chance for a minimum of 30 days.

    @Lee: Rec’d the same email message from Tal. Sounds like he’s warning the TMR (non-Cloner) traders to be careful in this market.

    Will continue updating. Good luck to all!!!

  29. Have you all been trading strategy 3 or the other two? My first trade on strategy 3 was a small loss so I decided to turn it off until the beginning of the month. Have had no trades on the other two strategies but presumed that Tal has not signaled any as he implied in his email. Does anybody know if strategy 3 works off the EA rather than getting signals from Tal as I was getting loads of trades from S3 which should not have been possible if Tals was keeping to his rules? Hoping to get some trades next week

  30. Appears TM (non-Cloner)’s putting up a lot of entry signals tonight during the Asian session. Lots of direction changes. I didn’t enter any since I’m mainly interested in the Cloner but seems many of these trades would have gotten stopped out. Would be interesting to see the results.

  31. Got this EA running on 2 Demo accounts. 1 is 5 digits and the other 4.

    So far Strategy 3 has been churning out a lot of signals but, because I only take them if the Signal Entry checklist is all positive in line with the user manual recommendations, I have actually only been able to trade 6 signals, 5 of which lost. I tracked many of the signals that I did not take to see what would have happened. Most of them lost as well.

    Last night at 9pm something really strange happened. One account showed a Buy signal and the other a Sell signal. 2 opposing signals at the same time?

    I can’t comment on the Cloner service. I did not sign up for it because he said that Signals machine was made up of the strategy’s that he uses for his own trading so I didn’t see the point of paying twice for the same thing. But I did get the email that has been referred to.

    My interpretation of that is that he’s basically saying that even if the Signals machine is operated in strict accordance with the rules in the manual, he still doesn’t have confidence to trade those signals/strategy’s himself at the moment. So how can he expect anyone else to have confidence?

    Perhaps my interpretation is wrong but, based on my own results with the EA, I am beginning to see why there is an apparent lack of confidence

  33. Hi Everyone

    Adding to my earlier posts I’m going to give up on this EA and in fact all EA’s as the results are far too unpredictable. I don’t think Tal Herman is a bad guy and I stand by my original comments that the installation was easy and the manual supplied is clear too. The trouble is the product needs babysitting so you have to be at your PC whilst the EA is running as signals have been suggested by the product and I’ve taken them but the TP level is not getting reached when the market is choppy then the market reverses and you hit the SL. This has resulted in loss after loss which is a pity. Here are the details of my trades though I will no longer be using this product;

    There are 33 trades and 9 cancelled trades (these were suggested by the program but not taken following Tal’s email detailed above in a previous post regarding trading). Cumulative loss is $785.00. Some of the trades were manually closed out to prevent further loss or to lock in profits but this was done due to the volatility of the pair over a couple of days this week.

    10543193 2011.01.17 16:56 buy 0.10 gbpusd 1.5895 1.5900 1.5948 2011.01.17 17:24 1.5900 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.00
    10543830 2011.01.18 02:56 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5926 1.5906 1.5956 2011.01.18 08:33 1.5956 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    10544795 2011.01.18 01:09 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5918 1.5898 1.5948 2011.01.18 07:50 1.5948 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    10546161 2011.01.17 20:19 sellstp 0.75 gbpusd 1.5863 1.5883 1.5833 2011.01.20 00:11 1.5984 cancelled
    10546313 2011.01.17 20:54 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5888 1.5868 1.5918 2011.01.18 01:03 1.5910 0.00 0.00 0.00 165.00
    10546836 2011.01.17 21:46 sellstp 0.75 gbpusd 1.5868 1.5888 1.5838 2011.01.20 00:11 1.5984 cancelled
    10547879 2011.01.17 23:00 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5891 1.5867 1.5923 2011.01.18 01:03 1.5910 0.00 0.00 0.00 142.50
    10551140 2011.01.18 02:56 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5925 1.5905 1.5955 2011.01.18 08:33 1.5955 0.00 0.00 0.00 225.00
    10561260 2011.01.18 10:03 buy 0.75 gbpusd 1.5981 1.5960 1.6010 2011.01.18 10:30 1.6010 0.00 0.00 0.00 217.50
    10567699 2011.01.18 11:25 buy stp 1.00 gbpusd 1.6054 1.6034 1.6084 2011.01.20 00:11 1.5991 cancelled
    10584885 2011.01.18 18:36 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5963 1.5983 1.5933 2011.01.18 18:50 1.5983 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    10586729 2011.01.18 20:59 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.5978 1.5958 1.6008 2011.01.18 21:05 1.5958 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    10587609 2011.01.18 21:30 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5963 1.6004 1.5896 2011.01.18 21:50 1.5961 0.00 0.00 0.00 20.00
    10588317 2011.01.18 22:25 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.5964 1.5944 1.5994 2011.01.19 02:28 1.5994 0.00 0.00 0.00 300.00
    10589423 2011.01.19 11:20 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5943 1.5963 1.5913 2011.01.19 11:24 1.5963 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    10590152 2011.01.19 11:20 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5945 1.5966 1.5916 2011.01.19 11:25 1.5966 0.00 0.00 0.00 -210.00
    10590747 2011.01.19 11:20 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5945 1.5965 1.5915 2011.01.19 11:25 1.5965 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    10602816 2011.01.19 08:19 buy 1.00 eurusd 1.3483 1.3421 1.3681 2011.01.19 08:21 1.3477 0.00 0.00 0.00 -60.00
    10603042 2011.01.19 08:34 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.6035 1.6014 1.6064 2011.01.19 08:49 1.6014 0.00 0.00 0.00 -210.00
    10606992 2011.01.19 13:52 buy 1.00 gbpusd 1.6035 1.6015 1.6065 2011.01.19 14:06 1.6015 0.00 0.00 0.00 -200.00
    10611610 2011.01.19 11:00 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5981 1.6039 1.5961 2011.01.19 11:17 1.5961 0.00 0.00 0.00 350.00
    10615109 2011.01.19 12:55 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5997 1.5977 1.6027 2011.01.19 13:51 1.6027 0.00 0.00 0.00 525.00
    10627679 2011.01.19 17:36 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5998 1.5978 1.6028 2011.01.19 18:38 1.5978 0.00 0.00 0.00 -350.00
    10628820 2011.01.19 17:36 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5997 1.5977 1.6027 2011.01.19 18:38 1.5976 0.00 0.00 0.00 -367.50
    10632167 2011.01.19 19:11 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5997 1.5977 1.6027 2011.01.19 20:54 1.5977 0.00 0.00 0.00 -350.00
    10634463 2011.01.19 21:27 sellstp 1.75 gbpusd 1.5975 1.5995 1.5945 2011.01.20 00:12 1.5988 cancelled
    10635104 2011.01.19 22:04 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5994 1.5974 1.6024 2011.01.20 00:54 1.5974 0.00 0.00 0.00 -350.00
    10636143 2011.01.19 23:19 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5984 1.6004 1.5954 2011.01.20 02:14 1.5954 0.00 0.00 0.00 525.00
    10638006 2011.01.20 00:20 buy stp 1.75 gbpusd 1.5999 1.5979 1.6029 2011.01.20 00:21 1.5987 cancelled
    10647090 2011.01.20 10:20 sellstp 1.75 gbpusd 1.5961 1.5981 1.5931 2011.01.20 10:41 1.5988 cancelled
    10650862 2011.01.20 13:57 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5975 1.5995 1.5945 2011.01.20 14:08 1.5974 0.00 0.00 0.00 17.50
    10653778 2011.01.20 14:38 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5957 1.5977 1.5927 2011.01.20 14:45 1.5955 0.00 0.00 0.00 35.00
    10653872 2011.01.20 14:12 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5975 1.6005 1.5945 2011.01.20 14:16 1.5973 0.00 0.00 0.00 35.00
    10659312 2011.01.20 16:46 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5853 1.5873 1.5823 2011.01.20 17:01 1.5848 0.00 0.00 0.00 87.50
    10659408 2011.01.20 16:35 sell 1.00 gbpusd 1.5870 1.5923 1.5753 2011.01.20 16:38 1.5869 0.00 0.00 0.00 10.00
    10662382 2011.01.20 18:31 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5895 1.5874 1.5924 2011.01.20 19:19 1.5882 0.00 0.00 0.00 -227.50
    10663494 2011.01.20 19:19 sellstp 1.75 gbpusd 1.5877 1.5897 1.5847 2011.01.20 19:20 1.5883 cancelled
    10665709 2011.01.20 21:47 sellstp 1.75 gbpusd 1.5891 1.5911 1.5861 2011.01.20 21:54 1.5897 cancelled
    10677083 2011.01.21 09:13 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5939 1.5745 1.6005 2011.01.21 10:57 1.5880 0.00 0.00 0.00 -1 032.50
    10683007 2011.01.21 13:23 buy 1.75 gbpusd 1.5945 1.5925 1.5975 2011.01.21 13:51 1.5948 0.00 0.00 0.00 52.50
    10690741 2011.01.21 17:42 buy stp 1.75 gbpusd 1.6012 1.5992 1.6042 2011.01.21 17:59 1.5998 cancelled
    10691025 2011.01.21 18:43 sell 1.75 gbpusd 1.5985 1.6005 1.5955 2011.01.21 18:49 1.5993 0.00 0.00 0.00 -140.00

    I won’t be commenting further on this product as I will no longer use it for the reasons discussed above.

    Best wishes to all
    Lee

  34. Lee, have you been using strategy 3 as I believe, though I may not be right, that these signals are self generated and not from Tal, otherwise he would be breaking his own rules not to trade the S3 after the first 5 days of the month etc.I would be interested in your opinion regarding this.

  35. Hi Lee,
    Just an observation but in your list of trades on 19th Jan at 08.19 no. 10602816 the EA traded EUR/USD. Strange, as it is only meant to trade GBP/USD. How come?

  37. I had got some problem of Cloner’s connection, then it backed in action. So when I contact Signal Machine Support I also asked them about 4 trades traded automatic by Cloner which 1 wining and 3 loss. I received an answwer on my question from SM Support, this is their answer :-

    Hi Ali,

    Thank you for your mail.

    I am glad the problem was resolved.

    Signals Machine is a high quality software that has been rigorously tested and operated on live accounts with remarkable success rates.

    If you’re trading manually or with an automated robot, you should be willing to accept losing trades. You can’t have a 100% accuracy rate and can’t cover every combination of market movements.

    Please make sure to apply Signals Machine to GBPUSD H1 chart only, and to use the additional trading recommendations provided on the Strategy Guide and user guide, and to only trade during the recommended hours.

    Generally, in order to avoid large losses to your account, you should use low leverage.

    Please let me know if you have further questions.

    We hope this response has sufficiently answered your questions. If not, please do not send another email. Instead, reply to this email or login to your account for a complete archive of all your support requests and responses.

  38. @Bob

    Apologies, my fault. I am testing other strategies on my MT4 platform too and when I exported the Statement my aim was to remove the non GBPUSD trades via Notepad. This one slipped under the radar!

    Well spotted though Bob 🙂

  39. Lee. Ah, that explains it. (Picky Picky Bob!) You have still not said which stategies you are getting losses on? I am still convinced that Srategy 3 trades are EA manufactured rather than sent from Tal,

  40. Hi Bob

    I purchased the EA package, others have referred to it on here as TMR. I did not pay for the Cloner package from Tal. The EA suggests buy / sell signals and it is at my discretion whether to place or not.

    Hope this helps.

  41. Interesting stuff Lee, thank you. I noticed the numerous trade signals and noticed most would have been stopped out. Passed on trading the signals when it appeared they were changing directions quite frequently at losses. I’m sticking with testing the Cloner to see how it goes.

  42. Hi K-Boy

    What worries me is that I purchased the cheapest option so need to manually process the trade though one of the upsells was to automate this process. If I had taken this option then the losses would have been greater as the signals would have become trades.

    I can’t comment on Tal’s cloner package as I did not elect to buy this so it will be useful for me to check back later to see how this works and performs.

    Best wishes

  43. For some reason the Cloner keeps taking two simultaneous trades. It lost me two lots of £17.50 the other day. Today it made a profit of .25p and a loss of .13p. .12p profit – GREAT! I have asked for an explanation of why this is happening.

  44. Hi bought it with all the bells and whistles up to now 6 trades 6 losses quarter of my account wiped out,asked for a refund.Not impressed

  45. @ Lee:
    Understand your concern.

    However, I’m noticing the Cloner trades are pretty infrequent compared to all the signals. Cloner’s clearly not taking all signal indicators. Trades seem to be occurring during the London session.

    Trade #5 & #6 closed at break even. Net is still @ -107 pips.

  47. Made a profit of £9 this morning. A little way to go to rein in my losses and the cost of the EA. Oh well there is always hope!

  49. Had two more losses this morning. The Cloner keeps making simultaneous double trades. My total loss now is £95.99, £ not $. My total gains are £16.98. Not a very good win to loss ratio! I like the layout of the chart which is clear and tells you what’s going on. The signals seem to be poor. Either Tal is not very good with his predictions or I am inclined to think that the signals are computer generated as it would not be cost affective if Tal and his team were add infinitum sending signals as they would require a monthly fee for such a service. I shall need a refund just to get some of my money back. Shame, as it was a nice interface to use.

  50. Cloner update:

    Trade #8-#13 closed for a net of -116. Total net of -193 from 7 trading days. Not off to a good start. Will continue to demo this for 30 days and see what happens.

  51. Bought the whole package and after just over 2 weeks and £150 approx down (another loss this morning on the automatic trade) its time for a refund.

    This loss would have been much worse if I had just taken the trades as they were offered but after initially just going with them realised that this was NOT a good option.

    The automatic trades, as someone has already mentioned, generated 2 trades sometimes… why? You have no control over these trades and as an example yesterday 2 trades were entered and they managed to go from a healthy position to hitting the SL’s! No automatic intervention was made to trade these out for a profit, which was ridiculous if these were actually Hal’s own trades. Personally I think these trades are computer generated as well.

    The software is easy to install and looks very nice, with strength pillars, nice graphics etc but I think most people could do a better job just using basic indicators.
    Luckily I was only demo trading but ag

  52. I love reviews they are the best, I’ve learnt a very good lesson, and it is to get our before you jump in!

    Thanks for all the reviews guys! You’re the best.

  53. sorry I had to amend the above e-mail because of my voice activation program didn’t say the right thing, but it does work quite well, it is because I can’t type to save my life and what you are hearing me say is exactly what I’ve said to the computer, below is exactly what I should have said if my voice activation had got it right the first time!

    I love reviews they are the best, I’ve learnt a very good lesson, and it is! “to check it out before you jump in!

    Thanks for all the reviews guys! You’re the best.

  55. Thanks all for your comments. Is there ANY EA that actually works, or is this looking for the Pot o’Gold at the end of the proverbial rainbow?
    God’s best to you.
    Over ‘n’ out.

  56. Last night was up $30 then woke up this am and down $40…arggg. All standard settings. Seems the Eur/usd was to blame for 3 out of 4 bad trades. Perhaps I should take off that pair or see what other bad trades are trending against me. I did add gold and no lost on it yet ( one day only).

    any suggestions? move stop losses or TP?Thinking about using this as a indicator to trade opposite.. any thoughts?
    Garry

  57. guys i am a newbie i have purchased a produck and not satisfide,so i want to get my refund but when i purchased the produck via paypal,and the vendor of produck i buy just only can refund via clickbank,so what should i do to get refund anyone here can help me to explained step by step how i can get my refund

  58. Hi buddis,

    been reading all this comments about people not being happy and getting refunds back so just woundered if any one that has thier refund could share the EA with me, well just email it to me at netfinders99 at aol thanks. Hope I am not being cheeky. Lol

  59. Hello everyone,

    So far I trade 3 days with the Signals Machine and I am very happy with the results – everyday profits, also some losses but much more profits than losses. I have over 100 Forex systems and EA’s but this one is by far the best.
    I can only hope it will continue to make profits every day.
    It is ment for the GBP/USD but I do also trade EUR/USD with success.

  60. I bought this several days ago. It I have taken 3 trades with many signals. I put a horizontal bar where the signal said to get in and sure enough all would have hit the SL. The 3 trades I did put on also hit the SL. I am not a newbie and have been trading for a number of years so inexperience is not the problem. The real problem here is we have all been scammed by this bastard. I bought this piece of crap system very cheap so for me it really doesn’t matter however i would absolutely get a refund as soon as possible. This system does not work at all and you will suffer loss after loss. Good luck

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.